Pumpkin Beer-Off 2010
Ah fall. The time when Things Must Taste Like Pumpkin. Pumpkin pie, pumpkin soup, and, most importantly, pumpkin beer.

In order to get a head up on the upcoming Fall and choose our official Fall 2010 Pumpkin Beer, we decided to do a bit of a taste test, coming home from the Coop with six pumpkin brews, splitting one 12-ounce bottle each for healthy 6-ounce pours. Because, it’s not just spending the evening splitting a sixer with your live-in partner when you’re doing it for science!
We kept notes while tasting, which we’ll share with you now. For your benefit, here are the results:
1. Will Stevens Pumpkin Ale, ? ABV ($1.46)
Wolaver’s/Otter Creek Brewing Company Vermont
Caroline: First impression: cloyingly sweet. Second impression: OK I get the crispness but I’m still not feeling the pumpkiness. I almost taste coffee. But mostly, I can close my eyes and feel like I’m drinking frat party beer. Also, Anthony just said “mouthfeel.”
Grade: C+
Anthony: Light and crisp, pumpkin taste is present, but almost as a bitter pumpkin-y aftertaste.
It tastes a bit like they tried to bring out a cinnamon flavor for the pumpkin pie effect, but couldn’t pull it off.
Mouthfeel is nothing special; a bit watery. On further tasting, I still don’t get anything like the sweetness Caroline complained of at first. It actually tastes like a reasonably smooth-drinking ale, not very heavy, with a subtle pumpkin taste, and then with a jarring bitterness from nowhere. My guess here is that either the pumpkin or one of the spices produced that taste when added to the brew.
Grade: B-
2. Buffalo Bill’s Pumpkin Ale, 5.2% ABV ($1.41)
Buffalo Bill’s Brewery, California
Caroline: “oooh! I like this one. Pumpkiny AND delicious!” The “mouthfeel” (heh) is pleasantly thick and creamy on my tongue. (also, heh). Not too bitter or too sweet. Also it’s a pretty color. But I don’t think I could drink more than a half a bottle of this. it is intense.
Grade: B+
Anthony: I’ve gotta say, this does have an impressive first taste that truly smacks of baked pumpkin flesh. smells vaguely of pie.
It baffles me what the people of Seattle would really know about pumpkin, but this is definitely a solid effort. The Wolaver’s I found increasingly bitter with more sips, to the point where I was overwhelmed. Also, on further tasting a subtle bubblegum taste (actually quite nice!).
This beer had an impressive first taste, but after 1/4 pint I feel like the pumpkin punch wore off. This is the beer I would say came of tasting like an underwhelming ale.
Grade: B
3. Post Road Pumpkin, 5.0% ABV ($1.41)
Brooklyn Brewery, Utica, NY
Caroline: It’s got a more subtle pumpkin taste, perhaps also an almondy character? More sophisticated than the ones we’ve had so far, which seemed to be going more for the overpowering sweet pumpkiny flavor. This is more like pumpkin….after hours. So far this is the one I could drink for the longest. I would even go for a second round with this one!
Grade: A-
Anthony: Hmmm this smells different! Definitely a different pumpkin aroma than Buffalo Bill’s. This beer had a nice bold first sip that I liked quite a bit. Though I did get a hint of that bitterness like the Wolaver’s. Definitely a nutty flavor, moreso than the distinctly squashy flavor of the last one.
Again I’d have to say that the bitterness grows more noticeable with time (is this just the tragic flaw of pumpkin beer?). But unlike the Wolaver’s this beer still remains not just drinkable, but enjoyable.
Grade: B+
4. Imperial Pumpkin Ale, 8.0% ABV ($2.62)
Weyerbacher Brewing Company, Pennsylvania
Caroline: smells like “ “autumn harvest” scented potpourri. it’s like they put apple cider seasonings in a beer! Noticing that same bubblegum flavor Ant picked up in the Buffalo Bill’s. But not so much of the pumpkin taste. I’m not sure if I love this, it’s almost like it’s trying too hard.
Grade: B
Anthony: Dang, but that has a spice kick like nobody’s business. Rich and full flavor. If anything, a bit light on the pumpkin and big on the spices, but pretty tasty. Reminiscent of what i remember the harpoon Winter Warmer tasting like, although I imagine side by side this would come out stronger in flavor than the harpoon. I notice that the bottle lists the spices used (unlike most of the pumpkin ales, which go for the generic “with pumpkin and spices”) and includes not the typical cinnamon/nutmeg/clove trifecta of pumpkin pie spice but also cardamom. Cardamom is one of my favorite spices but i’m not getting any real hint of it in this beer.
Ramona: mnnnnnnnnnnnk (that would be out cat Ramona, as she hopped up on the laptop to share her thoughts on the beer).
Grade: mnnnnnnnnnnnk (A-)
5. Arcadia Jaw-Jacker, 6.0% ($1.59)
Arcadia Brewing Company, Michigan
Caroline: Stupid name. More pumpkin-y than Weyerbacher or Wolaver’s. Also, it has a cinammony aftertaste!
Grade: B
Anthony: Darker color than any of the beers so far (even the Weyerbacher), just as a first impression. Definitely less spice-punch than Weyerbacher, but it’s also a challenge to detect the flavor after having my tastebuds assaulted. I’m actually liking it fairly well. NOTE: not actually a pumpkin beer, although for just a ‘pumpkin spice’ beer it does a decent job of faking it. Probably a step above Wolaver’s.
Grade: B?
6. Fisherman’s Pumpkin Stout, 6.75% ABV ($1.66)
Cape Ann Brewing Company, Massachusetts
Caroline: I don’t usually care for stouts that much but I do like this one! I taste a very subtle hint of pumpkin but appreciate that this one manages pumpkiny without the cloying sweetness.
In other news, I am really fucking sick of drinking pumpkin beer. How many more months of this?
Grade: Really fucking sick of pumpkin beer.
Anthony: Nice, smooth toasted malt taste. Kinda masks any pumpkin or spices that might be lurking underneath. Definitely a refreshing break from the weyerbacher and the arcadia, both of which had a much thicker feel. The stout is lighter (as per usual) but not terribly pumpkin-y.
Grade: B+
Conclusions: Caroline and I differ in our tastes, but there are some takeaway lessons for most anyone interested in pumpkin beer. For one thing, avoid Wolaver’s weak attempt. If you’re looking for a nice pumpkin taste in a beer you could have 2-3 of, Post Road is not a bad bet. For my money, the best out there are the serious ales like Weyerbacher’s Imperial that combine a big pumpkin taste with a considerable alcohol punch (not reviewed here is Southern Tier’s Pumpking, which they also sell at our Coop, ad is widely held to be one of the best pumpkin beers out there). And I’m also partial to the subtler taste of Fisherman’s Stout, but that might not be to everyone’s taste. It all depends what you’re in the market for.